Compare two explanations for your difficulties — the threat-based explanation (Theory A) and the anxiety-based explanation (Theory B) — to guide treatment focus.
This worksheet helps you step back and consider two possible explanations for your experience. Theory A is usually the explanation your anxiety gives you (e.g. "I have a serious illness"). Theory B is an alternative explanation (e.g. "I have a problem with health anxiety"). For each theory, list the supporting evidence, then consider which theory better fits the facts and what each theory suggests you should do about it.
Use when the client is stuck between two explanations for their experience: the threat-based interpretation (Theory A) and an alternative, often anxiety-based interpretation (Theory B). Originally developed for OCD and health anxiety but highly applicable in depression when comparing 'I am worthless/defective' (Theory A) with 'I have a belief that I am worthless, maintained by depression' (Theory B).
Present both theories side by side: 'Let me offer you two possible explanations for what's happening. Theory A is the one your depression gives you. Theory B is an alternative. Let's write both out and look at the evidence for each, and see which one better fits all the facts.'
For depression, adapt Theory A to capture the depressive belief and Theory B to capture the CBT formulation account. For clients who struggle with abstract reasoning, use concrete examples and analogies. For those who intellectually prefer Theory B but emotionally feel Theory A is true, validate this discrepancy and use it as a focus for further work.
Avoid if the client cannot yet consider alternative perspectives or is so entrenched in their belief that presenting an alternative feels invalidating. Not appropriate as a first-session intervention; requires sufficient rapport and cognitive model understanding.
The power of this tool lies in the client generating evidence for both theories rather than being told which is correct. Theory B should not simply negate Theory A but offer a genuinely coherent alternative explanation. Use the two-theory framework as an ongoing reference point throughout treatment.
Suitable for clients working with theory a theory b, cbt, health anxiety, ocd, cognitive restructuring, formulation. This tool can be used as a standalone worksheet or as part of a structured homework plan.
Create a free account to access 10 professional CBT tools per month.
The classic cognitive restructuring tool. Identify automatic thoughts, evaluate the evidence, and develop more balanced alternatives.
Identify your core values and assess how well your current activities align with them — then plan changes to close the gap.
Build a hierarchy of feared situations ranked by anxiety level, from least to most challenging, to guide graded exposure work.
A structured 6-step safety plan for crisis intervention and suicide prevention.